When Worlds Collide
dir Rudolph Maté, 1951, US, 83m
cast Richard Derr, Barbara Rush, Larry Keating, Peter Hansen
cin W. Howard Greene, John F. Seitz m Leith Stevens
_____________________________________________________________
Astronomers predict that a world (or rather a sun) will collide with Earth, destroying everything – effectively wiping out the human race. This world/sun is Bellus, but before that happens, another planet, Zyra, will pass close by earth. This near-collision will result in earthquakes and tsunamis.
Dave Randall (Richard Derr), a rogue and pilot, is paid to take the secret information of earth’s doom to London, to scientists that are going to varify the terrible information. The information turns out to be correct and the scientists start to plan their escape from earth. They hope that it is possible to fly into space and land on Zyra, which will (hopefully) be suitable for humans.
Randall suddenly finds himself in the middle of this whole affair, in love with the daughter of one of the scientists. This may also be his ticket aboard the ship to Zyra. However, Randall may be a rogue, but he also has a conscience. When it is time to choose which 40 people will make the journey, Randall gives up his seat. He does not feel that he has earned the right, that there are other more worthy people to take the seat.
This might be so, but when the time comes to leave earth, Randall finds an unlikely ally that may help him out in the hour of need…
_____________________________________________________________
When Worlds Collide is an old movie. It certainly has a story that it wish to explore, but with today’s knowledge, the thought of a planet (or maybe even two) crashing into earth seems… ludicrous. Sure, a comet, astroid or even a meteor would have been fine, but two planets passing through earth’s orbit within a month… I don’t think so. Of course, I am not a scientist nor an astronomer.
I know this movie was made in a different time, but I can’t help but wonder about the reactions of the people when they hear that earth is doomed. I would have thought that people would panic, but they don’t, only in the very last second when Bellus is within a stone’s throw. Sure, they might not believe in the information, but they must when the big red thing gets closer. To destroy earth is a pretty reckless thing, I don’t think a little emotion is too much to ask.
Another thing that really annoyed me. The ending. I don’t mind the people reaching Zyra, nor that the planet is suitable for humans. What really annoys me was the use of a painted landscape. This might not have looked fake back in 1951 (although I think it did, unless the movie was in black and white originally), but it does today and when the landscape looks distinctly like earth, I can’t help but wonder if they couldn’t have found a real location somewhere, like in Asia? I won’t even comment on the strange climate zones on Zyra (heavy snow and then 50 ft. away… a beautiful green meadow).
Was there nothing that I liked in this movie? There certainly was. The character of Dave Randall, for one. He feels real and seems disturbed by the thought of dying in so young age. He acts cool, but also human when disaster strikes. I also liked the pace of the movie. Strangely enough, the movie does keep you entertained, maybe for the wrong reasons (the movie is quite funny), but still.
As far as references go, there is a scene where New York is flooded, which reminded me of The Day After Tomorrow (Roland Emmerich, 2004), but also of 2012 (Roland Emmerich, 2009), where the humans built an ark of their own, only this one isn’t supposed to leave earth. Of course the last is a biblical reference.
Lastly, I just saw that they are working on a new When Worlds Collide movie which is supposed to hit the cinemas in 2012. I can only hope that it is better than the original.
When Worlds Collide won’t make it into my canon. The story is just too unbelievable and the scenery looks like something from a set. Sure this movie might have inspired other movies (like Armageddon and Deep Impact), but I doubt it. These movies would have been made even without this one.
